My grandmother, like any self-respecting Jewish grandmother, gave me lots of advice. Lately, I am on a mission to act on it because as she told me, “You get to be 94 years old, and if you are at least a little intelligent, you know a thing or two.”
She often lectured on the importance of education and lamented that she wasn’t able to get a good one (she was 18 when she was taken to Auschwitz) but I think she was one of the wisest people I knew. Life and experience are the greatest teachers, and her teacher was exacting and rigorous, and patient.
Here’s the first advice I am following:
“Just try.”
What am I trying? At the moment, I am trying to write.
I always wanted to be a writer but I have so much self-doubt and “Who do you think you are” and doubt in general like, “How do you know you will really like it?” and “What if you get bored of it?” and “you aren’t good enough at it” and “you’re cringe” and “it is an oversaturated market,” and “you’ll never make enough money with it,” and, and, and…I can go on but I am sure you get the point.
I was always a type A kind of person. I wish I could do the things I know will grant me stability and success. If I could control my life to the T, I would. I love to learn, analyze, understand, and break things down neatly. It is weird to me that there is this creative, uncontrollable, writer part of me that wants to come out no matter how much I try to stuff it back down. I don’t understand exactly why but it is just something I want to do, something I need to do. But refer to paragraph one for all the reasons not to.
Here is what my grandmother told me:
“You worked very very hard, and you should know, you’re very very talented,” (all of her grandchildren were of course very very smart, talented, and beautiful, and just the best in the whole entire world and she would mix up the word biased with prejudice so after she would overflow the most biased compliments on us she would say, “and I am not prejudice, this is just the truth.”) no matter what is going to happen. You can never figure out what is happening in life from one minute to the other. So, some things that I see aren’t going I don’t say stop it – I don’t say that. You try. If it isn’t good here, you go farther and farther, and you see. It’s not always everything is up to us but if you try then you know that you’re doing something. You don’t say no I can’t do it. You try and this should give you credit. That should give you the good feeling that you had the opportunity to do it. You never know when things will come up. Sometimes it takes years for something will wake up again. So, we hope. That’s it.”
I am working on my second book, my first novel, and all I am doing is trying. I sit down every day and write, quieting the voice in my head asking if I am wasting my time, if I will make money from it, and if it will even get published. I am writing because I am trying, because I want to, because I love it, and the process of writing, the process of trying, feels even better than the results.
I have seen this true time and time again. It isn’t the success that makes you feel good. It is the trying, the actual doing of what I love that fills me up. Maybe this is cliché but it is the journey over the destination. And you can always recalculate. You can always choose another path. You can always keep trying because you will never know until you try.
Another thing I have realized is that success doesn’t make you more confident. I am writing my second book now and my first book sold far beyond projection, was bought in twelve languages, and got beautiful reviews (which I appreciate more than you know) yet I am still doubting my ability to write a book. All these things I know and can speak about over and over again but apparently, there are galaxies separating my mind from my heart. And so I will keep trying to keep trying. I will, “just try.” Not just succeed, not just plan, not just argue for the case why I should. Just try.
My grandmother would tell you the same thing. Try doing the things you love, the things that light your day up. Try doing what you want. Because the joy isn’t in the success. The joy isn’t in the accomplishment. The joy is in the trying. The merit is in the trying. In Judaism, you are never rewarded on the outcome, only for your effort. One of my favorite quotes is, “is not onto you to complete the task, but neither are you free to abandon it.” – Pirkei Avot.
Yesterday, I went into this amazing used bookstore and my writing insecurities resurfaced. I felt overwhelmed by the number of books that are out in the world. I wondered again if there was a need for the novel I was spending so many hours writing, there are already so many good books. Then I asked the bookseller if they carried my book, and he was so excited to tell me of course they do. He said it was a bestseller in his store and his readers liked it. It made me feel so good, that in a world where you have so much to read and so little time, you chose to read my grandmother’s story. I am beyond grateful to you all. This was my grandmother’s dream – and my dream too, and would never, ever have happened without you.
Thank you for being my readers. And if you’re thinking of writing, in a world that over saturated with junk, the best we can do is saturate it with books too. Or, as my Jewish grandmother would say, at least try to.
What are you trying this summer? I would love to hear in the comments.
Written by : Nechama Birnbaum
Nechama Birnbaum is the author of the award-winning, bestselling book, The Redhead of Auschwitz. Her work has been translated into eleven languages. She holds a Master of Science in Nutrition (but her true calling is writing). She teaches Creative Writing in Manhattan High School for Girls. She is a mom of three and their favorite pastime is reading piles and piles of picture books in bed.
I love to read your remarks about your very wise grandmother. She was truly worth emulating!! I read your book and I have recommended it to many, many people!
Thank you so much! This means the world to me.
I found you on Instagram, bought your book (& purchased it signed:). I devour all your writing & the advice is needed & your words are like no one else’s. I can’t wait for your 2nd book! I have 4 little kids (one an infant) and I’m 45. I’ve had a career, but I want to bake! So, that’s what I have been trying. Will anyone even like what I make? I care and I don’t because the process is just fun. That’s what I’m trying as of late. Cheers to you! Thank you for writing.
I love this!! Read the book Eat Cake, I think you’ll like it!
Thank you for your incredibly kind words. They keep me writing.
I will read it! Thank you for the rec!!!
Your Grandma was a blessing to you and so many people. She was a beautiful lady. I love how much Rosie loved her family and had so much advice. She wasn’t filled with hate after such a terrible experience. Every time you write, remind yourself of all the good things she taught you. You have been given a gift to share. Thank you for sharing yourself and your dear Bobbie.
Thank you so much. I love how you put this. It’s true, writing about her makes me remember what she taught me, and also helps me feel closer to her when she feels so far away.
Here is perhaps some wisdom…do not write because of ( fill in the blank) i.e., money, fame, if people will like it, blah blah blah. These do not matter. Write because of your love for writing and write only for yourself. Most novelist writers don’t sit down and say I need to write something that will be published or will make money. They write because of the love and creativity they have within that needs to come out of them. Not everyone will love what you write…some people think Shakkespeare is too hard to understand or Poetry is to flowery and blah blah blah. So write for yourself. That is it. Write for the sheer love of it. You wrote your Grandma’s story for love. And because of your love for your Grandma and the love of the story it did well. So write for the love of writing. That is it. The rest will follow. Every person who writes won’t be Voltaire. But every writer who writes does it for themselves for love…and if people like it great! If not who cares because you did it for the love of it. How can you go wrong if you put everything else aside such as ego, money, doubt, worry and do it for love?
Write for yourself for the love it.